The Jacket

A low-key picture with an intelligent screenplay, marvelous editing, good actors and an ending that does considerable damage to the structure so carefully built. Any other ending would have fitted better than the one that the makers used in the end. Even a fade-out would have made me happier than this. Of the considerably erratic acting performances by Adrien Brody, this role and his part in Summer of Sam are the very pinnacle of his promisingly advancing career. Too bad that he had to spoil these two outstanding performances with what he gets up to in The Village. A very pleasant movie surprise. (04/02/2007)

The Jacket is a film that should be appreciated for its interesting subject and cast, but the final execution disappointed me, especially in contrast to the very decent rating on FilmBooster. Unfortunately, my expectations were higher than what I watched. The plot seemed too chaotic to me, which was due to both the script and the direction, and there were logical inconsistencies in it. However, some moments certainly had a great atmosphere. In several cases, the crazy editing bothered me as well. Overall impression: 45%. (20/01/2009)

The director focused on individual details, but he couldn't perfectly piece together the whole. Technically, the film is brilliant. You can feel the rawness in the image (toning and filters) and there is not much sentimentality. However, several of the themes do not fit together completely in the end and you cannot help but feel that maybe you were expecting something more. The ethereal and very subdued music surprisingly has a strong effect and completes the already very oppressive atmosphere full of fear and loneliness. (10/12/2005)

The Jacket certainly wanted to offer a lot: the cruelty of a mental institution, time travel, and a strange romance. All this promised an atmospherically unpleasant spectacle, which director John Maybury more or less succeeds in doing. Partially combining the content of Forman's One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest and the taut visual form of Darren Aronofsky's Requiem for a Dream, it presents a raw spectacle that surprisingly doesn't feel like it was stolen from somewhere. The division of two time periods is done forcefully but non-intrusively, only with the help of camera stabilization and especially Keira Knightley's presence, who finally showcases an acting performance that surpasses even her physical attractiveness, because on a lady who "cools off" every puff of a cigarette with a good sip of rich liquid, there's not a lot to look at. Adrien Brody's radical weight loss is a testament to his efforts to get into the role properly, which he does very well. However, out of the whole collection of (semi)lunatics, Daniel Craig stands out the most, as he managed to instantly captivate all the attention despite having a smaller role. It took me a long time to decide how to evaluate The Jacket. My final decision to give it three stars is not so much an expression of a "happy medium" as it is a reasonable assessment of a film that, while offering a lot, ultimately delivers nothing anyway. (04/08/2005)

I have very mixed feelings. This film has a great premise, a rather depressing atmosphere, a phenomenal Brody and a lovely Knightley, but I still felt that a lot more could have been made out of it, that the script could have been a bit bolder at times, and that the symbiosis of all that mystery with the weak climax was as effective as shooting arrows to the air. I was very curious, but The Jacket is just another of the many time travel movies that differs significantly only in that it cleverly hides behind the alluring mask of a mental institution. Any comparison with 12 Monkeys is out of the question... 65% (17/12/2012)