Kaka

It's hard with this season. After the second season, which at times felt like a gunfight in the wild west, the third one is much more sedentary, with an emphasis on family ties and the feuds outside. This is especially true of the first half of the season, which moves along very slowly, with no major surprises. Everyone we love are just the way we love them. In addition, the creators managed to cast the supporting roles well. Q'orianka Kilcher, the fragile girl from The New World, is almost unrecognizable here, and the same goes for Will Patton, but both fit their roles perfectly. And just when it looks like we won't be seeing any butcher shop commercials like we did in the epic second season, the final episode comes along to convince us otherwise. I won't deny that some of the scenes are too over-the-top and fold in a bit of adrenaline rush towards the more mainstream viewer rather than functional and realistic, but it's still true that Yellowstone has brilliant writing and, within limits, realistic plots with twists and cliffhangers that mostly make sense. Plus, with its emphasis on old and modern traditions of a way of life, it's something to cherish it for more than just as consumerist entertainment.

Ahsoka has a great rollout, but a cranky, basically stumbling finale, in which several crucial things don't make much sense or are not explained, and those expecting an epic ending in the style of Episode 3 will be very disappointed. The opening has high ambitions. It has an excellent atmosphere and honours some of the traditions of the older Star Wars. Likewise, the fights are decently filmed. However, from the halfway point on, it's a stereotypical rehash without any invention or directorial initiative. Basically a weaker copy of the more entertaining The Mandalorian. The Hayden Christensen gimmick is not enough, although it is used solidly.

A grossly underdone finale with no proper denouement, no dramatic arc and not much suspense. Instead, we're served zombies, lots of magic that doesn't really belong in Star Wars, and it's crowned by the fact that most of the main characters make bizarre decisions that don't make much sense. The Jedi fights ring hollow and become monotonous over time.

The creators are dramatically running out of ideas and it starts to become a template piece with generic action and a loop of repetitive fights and wannabe cool scenes. A little bit like The Witcher, a little bit The Mandalorian, the fatalism is gone, plus we've got Jar Jar Binks-like critters. And mentioning that the in-universe scenes largely replicate the fantastic seismic charge sequence from Episode 2 is actually redundant.

Looks like a mix of The Mandalorian and Dune, but without the soul of either. It just copies and replicates some moments, visual ideas, or story construction verbatim.

Anakin rules. His return is well beyond expectations. Not only does he look great, but he hasn't forgotten how to swing a lightsaber. More than any other episode in the series, this is reminiscent of the fantastic Episode 3 in its unique charge.

The best episode so far, full of great shootouts, lightsaber duels and cut trees. Ray Stevenson is a charismatic bad guy.

A narrative episode cut from the older Star Wars. Imaginative space battles and whales in the sky at the end. Probably not the best episode, but perfect for SW geeks.

The dark toning continues and works well. A solidly shot fight on the docks and the overall short running time makes the whole fresh and dynamic. Similar to The Mandalorian for example.

A quite dark and atmospheric opening in the style of Rogue One and other modern Star Wars stories of recent times, which is a bit scented with the smell of Indiana Jones adventures with specific trademarks and artifacts. I appreciate the fact that they pull out almost all of the core characters right away, and even without knowing Rebels, it's been pretty fun so far.