Rosemary's Baby

Except for the last ten minutes, a masterpiece, brilliant in the way it confuses the viewer and encourages them to interpret the story in their own way. You can take it as a thoroughbred satanic horror film or, on the contrary, as a psychological drama of a woman gradually sinking into her paranoia, and Polanski's thoughtful direction doesn't make it any easier. On the contrary, thanks to many clever hints that can be interpreted in multiple ways, it builds the same sense of insecurity and paranoia in the viewer themselves. Unfortunately I have to agree with some of the reviews here that the ending is unsatisfying, it was a terrible disappointment for me. The cards are laid on the table all too clearly, everything is explained in a half-hearted manner and the wonderful atmosphere of uncertainty and suspicion falls to dust. If Polanski had left it open at the end, in the more ambiguous level of the whole narrative, I wouldn't have hesitated a second with the maximum rating. Such a shame. (17/02/2008)

The Atmosphere, the music and the actors are absolutely brilliant. The conclusion is well-executed, with solid direction. What bothered, however, me was the very slow start and it is already in a different league in terms of filmmaking, someone who did not grow up with this may find it quite hard to connect. (30/06/2004)

Excellent performances, music and direction, but it’s only around the middle that it gets a proper atmosphere, up until then it’s a pretty ordinary drama. The second half, however, is a brilliant portrayal of paranoia (similar to The Tenant, Polanski knows his stuff), but unfortunately it’s somewhat devalued by the overly literal ending, which may convey the idea of the relationship of mother and child, but at the cost of the atmosphere. Overall, though, Rosemary’s Baby is very good. (14/11/2008)

The diabolical Polanski, the angelic Mia Farrow, and their depressing crisis pregnancy manual wrapped in the garb of occult satanic madness. A masterpiece that is almost unrivalled in its genre in terms of atmosphere and story structure. The mismanaged finale it’s a great shame, if it weren't for that, this could have been the most intense horror experience of my life after the incomparable The Shining, instead of “only” a proper five-star movie. 90% (04/08/2013)

Levin's source material is famously well-drawn, apart from the slowly (but from a certain point onwards very intensely) escalating tension and unpredictability of the various characters, and – most importantly – the character of Rosemary is portrayed in such a sensitive and evocative way that identifying with her person, her suffering, and her fate must necessarily become an essential part of the overall experience (both of the book and the film, as Mia Farrow is wonderful under Polanski's direction). All the positives as I described them above are more or less successfully transferred to the film rendering (with excellent incidental music to boot), and at least in the first hour Polanski succeeds more than adequately in capturing the power of the atmosphere as depicted in the book (the first scene during Rosemary's dream is unforgettable.) But then it breaks somewhere (I can't pinpoint exactly where in the film), and what Levin managed to do in the novel (i.e. to keep a permanent sense of tension and uncertainty) doesn't strike me as credible in Polanski's rendition (of course, I'm very influenced by the book and its quality, but given the excellent first half of the film, my expectations were quite high afterwards) and the ending... Sure, it's the same as in the source material, but the overall odyssey to it and the final denouement just wasn't handled quite ideally, and honestly I was rather disappointed... However, as a whole, it's a very strong 4 stars somewhere in the 90% range. :) (24/11/2010)