Toni Erdmann

Toni Erdmann is one of the movies that you find out about and that you never forget. A German dramedy that takes 162 minutes? And on top of that generally praised and with an Oscar nomination? That’s strange, don’t you think? So I wanted to avoid all the strange theories and I decided to watch the movie. But the result was one big disappointment because I sure had not expected such an average movie. You see Toni Erdmann starts off very slowly. In the first 15 minutes, I was thinking that I would give it some time. The premise looked good, the length was brutal, so I’d let the movie run its course before forming an opinion. But the problem was that the movie had the same atmosphere for its entire duration of almost three hours. The teacher Winfried shocked me a bit at the start with his wackiness, but gradually the position of the misunderstood hero was taken over by his daughter, who was even wackier. But at that moment Winfried turned into Toni Erdmann and every now and then there was a scene that was supposed to be funny. I think I may have had a problem with the fact that I didn’t find them funny at all. Quite the opposite. I felt a great sadness in Winfried’s soul, which was trying to understand his daughter’s life in Romania, which I guess a normal person cannot even imagine, let alone Winfried. A very strange film that does have its interesting moments, but I really took nothing from it. And I had really been looking forward to it. (30/01/2017)

I could rave about how well the German filmmakers managed to handle a serious theme, but I'd be lying. I don’t think it takes a nearly three-hour film, where often nothing happens, to convey how a father and daughter have a different perspective on life. Perhaps I would have given a higher rating, but the runtime literally murdered the film and almost me with it. I gotta appreciate the excellent costume at the end of the film, to which I can only say Fish On. (17/06/2017)

Yes, it’s awesome. The initial impressions immediately after the screening were too stirred and I had a few reservations about some dull or superfluous scenes that disproportionately stretched this otherwise unprecedented (literally) great tragicomedy, but in hindsight they feel like a brilliant bridge between the sad and humorous passages across the whole unpredictable film. What is clear, though, is that I haven't laughed so heartily and been so genuinely moved in a long time, and that only another screening will help me discover how brilliant and emotionally balanced a film Toni Erdmann really is. So far, it has won me over. (28/10/2016)

Toni Erdmann is a very original drama with comedic elements imbued with a huge dose of humanity. At the beginning, I was a bit worried about the longer runtime, but after a few minutes, I was so drawn into the story that I felt like I was being blown through a centrifuge. I would like to highlight the performance of Peter Simonischek, who took on the role of the aged teacher Winfried Conrad in a completely disarming way. His efforts to reunite with his daughter, who had become a spineless careerist, were extremely heartwarming, even if he sometimes used some pretty annoying pranks to achieve his goal. Sandra Hüller, on the other hand, as the workaholic Ines, gradually began to resemble the image of a girl loved by her father, as clueless in life as she was in her childhood. It should be noted that both actors were amazing. In addition, there were quite a few situations in the film where I didn't know whether I was tearing up with laughter or with emotion. For the tangle of emotional outbursts and several unforgettable scenes, I simply have to give the film full marks. (17/07/2020)

“Are you even human?” Laughter through tears. Maren Ade’s third film is a sad costume comedy whose characters are most exposed thanks to the masks they wear. Their addiction to living in solitude and by their own rules both divides and unites Winfried and Ines. We see them alone for a substantial part of the film, at moments when the relieving effect of laughter reverberates and the awareness of a missed opportunity and irreversible estrangement returns. Unlike many contemporary American indie comedies and series, an awkard feeling is not an end in itself. Besides laughter, it evokes sympathy and relates to the key theme of humiliation and inadequacy. The characters feel this inadequancy with respect to each other, themselves and the world they live in. The film does not take the side of either of the characters, which is reflected in its structure and in the way situations that seem like a victory for Winfried suddenly turn in Ines’s favour. We spend roughly the first hour of the film with Winfried, who then suddenly disappears from the narrative with no promise of whether we will see him again. We then stay by Ines’s side for a while until Winfried’s reappearance, which is as unexpected as his departure. During the rest of the film, perspectives alternate in the manner of passing a baton. A scene begins with Ines, in whose life Winfried/Toni suddenly appears (sometimes indirectly, through his crafty way of relating to the world – see the erotic hotel scene) and with whom we stay even after Ines leaves the scene. The ease and unpredictability with which Ade combines comedy with tragedy, intimate drama with an account of socio-economic relations in globalised Europe is not the result of happy accidents and improvisation à la Dogme 95, but of precise work with editing and mise-en-scene, which prepares us in advance for some of the next scenes while creating false expectations. Thanks also to the masterful directing, we experience uncertainty, wonder, sadness, joy, humiliation, rejection, acceptance and catharsis at the same time with the characters, whom we don't want to leave behind after 160 minutes not because we feel good with them, but because we have so much in common with them. I’m sorry about only one thing: it is unlikely that I will see anything better (equally unpredictable, funny and sad) this year. 95% (07/10/2016)